Spiky Cartoonist John Callahan Gets His Own Kind of Memorial. It Might Not Offend You.

https://goo.gl/5EXdqr 

Death. Cruelty. Trouble. Carefree. Good. Praise.

Using just those six words, and a brain's response to them, researchers were able to identify suicidal individuals with 91% accuracy. It's a rather macabre success for a machine-learning algorithm, but the implications are fairly profound.

We're talking about this study, appearing in Nature Human Behaviour.

Words like death and cruelty differentially activated the left superior medial frontal area and the medial frontal/anterior cingulate in the individuals with suicidal ideation – these are areas associated with self-referential thought. Using a machine-learning algorithm the researchers successfully identified 15 of the 17 brains from those with suicidal ideation and 16 of the 17 controls.

Of course, the elephant in the room here is a 70,000-pound electromagnet.

"It would be nice to see if we could possibly do this using EEG, if we could assess the thought alterations with EEG. It would be enormously cheaper. More widely used."

The other thing to remember is that these volunteers told us they had suicidal ideation. That's the gold-standard that the computer was learning on. But, as I noted above, people who admit they are having suicidal thoughts are the easy ones – we need ways to figure out who is suicidal and not telling us. Just pointed out that mind-reading, so to speak, is a long way off for a simple reason:

"If somebody didn't want others to know what they are thinking, they can certainly block that method. They can not cooperate. I don't think we have a way to get at people's thoughts against their will."



views